著者
Tatsuya Noda Toshiyuki Ojima Shinya Hayasaka Chiyoe Murata Akihito Hagihara
出版者
Japan Epidemiological Association
雑誌
Journal of Epidemiology (ISSN:09175040)
巻号頁・発行日
vol.22, no.1, pp.45-49, 2012-01-05 (Released:2012-01-05)
参考文献数
25
被引用文献数
6 11

Background: Fever is one of the most common symptoms among children and is usually caused by respiratory infections. Although Japanese health authorities have long recommended gargling to prevent respiratory infections, its effectiveness among children is not clear.Methods: The children in this observational study were enrolled from 145 nursery schools in Fukuoka City, Japan. Children in the exposure group were instructed to gargle at least once a day. The endpoints of this study were incidence of fever during the daytime and incidence of sickness absence. Differences among gargling agents for each endpoint were also analyzed.Results: A total of 19 595 children aged 2 to 6 years were observed for 20 days (391 900 person-days). In multivariate logistic regression, the overall odds ratio (OR) for fever onset in the gargling group was significantly lower (OR = 0.68). In age-stratified analysis, ORs were significantly lower at age 2 (OR = 0.67), 4 (OR = 0.46), and 5 (OR = 0.41) years. Regarding sickness absence, the overall OR was 0.92 (not significant) in the gargling group. In age-stratified analysis, ORs were significantly lower at age 4 (OR = 0.68), 5 (OR = 0.59), and 6 (OR = 0.63) years. In subgroup analysis, significantly lower ORs for fever onset were observed for children who gargled with green tea (OR = 0.32), functional water (OR = 0.46), or tap water (OR = 0.70). However, the ORs were not significant for sickness absence.Conclusions: Gargling might be effective in preventing febrile diseases in children.

言及状況

外部データベース (DOI)

Twitter (4 users, 14 posts, 2 favorites)

Attempts to replicate this independently have also been inconclusive at best, despite a sample size of almost 20,000. This study has many of the same issues. https://t.co/mufZFSqckn
うがいは、小児の熱性疾患の予防に有効であるかもしれないという結論です。 まあ2歳で、まともなうがいができるかどうかはいささか疑問があるところですが、おおむねうがいで熱性疾患の予防が有効のようです。 https://t.co/qayuLNTp
病気による欠席に関しては、 全体の調整ORは、うがい群で0.92(0.84–1.00)で有意差は無かった。 年齢層別解析では、オッズ比は、4歳・5歳6歳で有意に低下https://t.co/qayuLNTp
年齢層別解析では、オッズ比は、2歳・4歳・5歳で有意に減少 2歳OR =0.67(0.53–0.86) 3歳 OR=0.75(0.52–1.08) 4歳OR= 0.46(0.26–0.80) 5歳OR =0.41(0.18–0.93) https://t.co/qayuLNTp
2歳~6歳までの19595例の小児を対象。観察期間は20日(391900人日)。多変量ロジスティック回帰分析で、うがい群ではうがいなし群に比べて 発熱の全体的な調整OR: 0.68(0.57–0.82)で有意に低かった。 https://t.co/qayuLNTp
日本の福岡における145保育施が対象。暴露群の小児は、少なくとも一日一回うがいをするように指示された。本研究のエンドポイントは、日中の発熱発生率と病気による欠席率。各エンドポイントのうがい剤の違いも分析。https://t.co/qayuLNTp
発熱は小児において最も一般的な症状の一つであり、通常は呼吸器感染によって引き起こされる。日本の保健当局は呼吸器感染症を防ぐためにうがい推奨しているが、小児において、その有効性は明らかではない。https://t.co/qayuLNTp
うがいで小児の発熱性疾患は減らせますか?という報告!Gargling for oral hygiene and the development of fever… J Epidemiol. 2012;22(1):45-9. https://t.co/qayuLNTp
@muku00001105 元文献ですね  RT これですね。英語読めません。。。 http://t.co/YlEtwcwf
@muku00001105 元文献ですね  RT これですね。英語読めません。。。 http://t.co/YlEtwcwf
@Nak_C @an523 これですね。英語読めません。。。 http://t.co/u88dfKL2
@Nak_C @an523 これですね。英語読めません。。。 http://t.co/u88dfKL2

収集済み URL リスト