著者

服部 英雄

出版者

九州大学大学院比較社会文化学府

雑誌

比較社会文化 (ISSN:13411659)

巻号頁・発行日

vol.14, pp.1-48, 2008

---

This is a Report of Symposiac examining the Maintenance of historic site and reconstraction of the historical buildings. Hattori reported about the restoration work of the Shimo-no-hashi-mon gate inside the Fukuoka-jyo castle. Fukuoka City is doing restoration works of Shimo-no-hashi-mon gate based on the image of old photo Kami-no-hashi-mon gate.The most similar building to this Shimo-no-hashi-mon gate and Kami-no-hashi-mon is honmaru-omote-mon gate. The window shutter of the honmaru-omote-mon gate is hung by the hinge and projected from the wall when it is open. In this style of window which is similar to Bahama shutter style, the window looks consecutive with the wall, and the number of windows can be doubled that of the sliding shutter style windows needing storage place behind the wall. The upper half of the Shimo-no-hashi-mon gate is a lattice and has holes through which you can shoot at the enemies. The restoration plan made by Fukuoka City assumed that the part colored white in the black and white photo was a wall and decided to make sliding shutter style windows on the wall. It is argued, however,the part coloured white is the shutter which made look lighter than it should be in the photo by overexposure. The restoration plan made by Fukuoka City has failed to catch the characters and values Fukuoka castle gates. In addition, it also points out that the restoration plan has made a mistake to make the passage of the second floor not passable. Prof Senda Yoshihiro explained the case that the Repair of various historical ruins,Monuments,rebuilding construction did not correct,therfor People did not correctly understand the history. For instance, Yamanaka jyo castle,Hachiouji jyo castle, and an Ozu castle, etc. Next Report is the discussion, the questionnaire and historical materials,Itami-Shiryo's introduction. The number of the cannon, the gun, and arms in the Fukuoka-jyo-castle is written in the introduced historical materials.