著者

原田 康夫 夜陣 紘治 平川 勝洋 中田 将風 竹林 脩文 築家 大介 黒川 道徳 村上 譲 菊屋 義則 野田 益弘 二宮 優子 笹 征史

出版者

耳鼻咽喉科臨床学会

雑誌

耳鼻咽喉科臨床 (ISSN:00326313)

巻号頁・発行日

vol.79, no.1, pp.161-172, 1986-01-01 (Released:2011-11-04)

参考文献数

15

被引用文献数

1

---

Patients with pharyngitis and tonsillitis were studied in a randomized double-blind trial to compare the clinical usefulness of MK212G and Isodine gargle.1. Of the 71 patients treated with MK212G or Isodine gargle, four were excluded because they were out of protocol. The results in the remaining 32 patients treated with MK212G and 35 patients treated with Isodine gargle were analyzed statistically.2. MK212G was effective in 93.8% and Isodine gargle in 85.7%, not a statistically significant difference (x2=3.807 N.S.).3. In the MK212G group, one patient complained of oral discomfort and in the Isodine gargle group, two patients had mild nausea and one had vomitting. The difference was not statistically significant (x2=1.165 N. S.).4. MK212G was considered to be clinically useful in 87.51% and Isodine gargle in 82.86%, not a statistically significant difference (x2=0.410 N. S.).5. The above results suggest that MK212G is as useful as Isodine gargle in the treatment of pharyngitis and tonsillitis.