- 著者
-
西野 真由美
- 出版者
- 日本倫理学会
- 雑誌
- 倫理学年報 (ISSN:24344699)
- 巻号頁・発行日
- vol.71, pp.203-217, 2022 (Released:2022-07-11)
The unity of virtue thesis, which states that the various virtues only hold different
names for the same concept, has a long history of controversy and is
among the most debated issues in contemporary virtue ethics. This idea, and especially
when interpreted as implying that an individual cannot possess a virtue
without possessing all the other virtues, sounds implausible from common experiences.
One dominant interpretation is that various virtues originate from the
same state of soul, from a sort of perceptual capacity. McDowell, one of the
leading advocates for the traditional Aristotelian formulation of the thesis,
holds that each virtue is a form of reliable sensitivity to a certain sort of requirement
from situations.
This article aims to explore the role of practical wisdom(phronesis)upon the
unity of virtue(s)in contemporary discussions. By showing how the unity of
virtue is compatible with the plurality and diversity of virtues under the direction
of practical wisdom, I intend to clarify the issue surrounding the unity of
virtue from a new perspective, thereby paving a way toward re-constructing a
new foundation for moral education, focusing on moral virtues as an integrated
entity, rather than as discrete dispositions.
First, upon more closely examining the conundrums that the unity of virtue
thesis poses for virtue ethics, I identify the problems which may put the feasibility
of the virtuous person, the central feature of virtue ethics, at stake. Second, I
examine the ideas of two main contemporary virtue-ethicists, Russell and Annas,
focusing on their views of the nature of practical wisdom and its relation
to the virtues as clusters. Third, I indicate the unity as a unified, open whole, involving practical wisdom which integrates the different moral requirements of a
concrete context with the agent’s appreciation of the situation’s features.
In conclusion, by drawing from the implications that the advocates of the unity
of virtue thesis in contemporary virtue ethics agree that the moral virtues
are closely connected, it is worthwhile to conceive virtue cultivation as being
based upon the developing of practical wisdom, which involves reflection and insight
on how to live well.