著者
菱田 信彦
雑誌
東京女子大学比較文化研究所紀要 (ISSN:05638186)
巻号頁・発行日
vol.78, pp.59-76, 2017-01-01

Elves and goblins in J. K. Rowling’s “Harry Potter” books seem to be rather different from their traditional images we see in British folktales. Rowling’s elves are pathetic, hardly able to act for their own sake, delighted only when they are treated well by witches and wizards. On the other hand, goblins are clever and assertive, and always stick to their goals. In Harry’s last battle with Voldemort told in the seventh book, a goblin, Griphook, plays a crucial part. It seems that in Rowling’s works goblins are given more positive roles than elves, which is not the case in most traditional folktales. However, learning to be kind to house-elves is also very important for Harry, because house-elves work best for those who are kind to them, and acquiring their help means a lot in the battles Harry fights. In the seventh book, Harry digs a grave for Dobby, the house-elf who has died to save him. Harry does this just for Dobby’s memory, not to get help from house-elves. This selfless service of Harry’s moves Griphook, usually a stubborn and defiant goblin, and he agrees to join forces with Harry in his task to defeat Voldemort. Elves and Goblins described in Rowling’s works show that just being kind can change the world.

言及状況

Twitter (8 users, 8 posts, 10 favorites)

@shanshan9645 三浦論文は今Webだと読めないので、英語圏の話を参照しかつWebで読める論も挙げてみます。例えば菱田信彦2017「従順なエルフと抵抗するゴブリン」https://t.co/P6B1hFZR0Dがあります。また、精読の下準備的なものですが、ハリポタと十二国を比較した研究ノート(高橋優佳,2018)も読めます。ご参考まで。
たまたま読んだ論文だけど、とてつもなく面白かった。日本語訳で切り捨てられた様々なところに作者のメッセージがあったことを気づかされる。 従順なエルフと抵抗するゴブリン ー「ハリー・ポッター」シリーズの魔法種族における価値の逆転ー https://t.co/IsdL5NrL1f
わりと面白かった。G・マクドナルド→トールキン→JKローリングの過程で、ゴブリンには英国のインド支配が背後にあるマクドナルド、他者の支配と抑圧の面が消えたトールキン、再びそれを取り上げたローリングという対比。 菱田信彦「従順なエルフと抵抗するゴブリン」(2017) https://t.co/U69Cr3ZEsD

収集済み URL リスト