文献一覧: 日本法哲学会 (出版者)

This paper aims to demonstrate the thesis that the duty to obey the law is not particular. To show this. I begin by examining the difference between the duty to obey the law and political obligation, though they are usually used interchangeably. I argue that aliens staying in a host state do have the former but not the latter. Thus the duty to obey the law does, pace John A. Simmons, not meet the particularity requirement, while political obligation does. The duty to obey the law is rather regarded as the duty to reach a global juridical state (status iuridicus), which is discussed by Immanuel Kant. I conclude that we owe political obligation only insofar as it is a useful way to discharge such a universal duty.

2022-10-02 22:34:00
1 はてなブックマーク

1 0 0 0 OA 遵法責務論への道

著者: 那須耕介
出版者: 日本法哲学会
雑誌: 法哲学年報 (ISSN:03872890)
巻号頁・発行日: vol.2008, pp.190-197, 2009 (Released:2021-12-29)

For the theory of the duty to obey the law. its introductory discussion is as important as its main discussion. In order to bring out the importance and role of theory of the duty to obey the law. we cannot avoid examining its practical significance as well as its theoretical specificity. Here I propose to focus not only on the traditional problem of 'evil law' but also on the problem of 'doubtful law'. Each provides the means to overcome the skepticism about the importance (or, theoretical specificity) of the theory of the duty to obey the law. The former, 'evil law' approach have pointed out that the concept of law's content-independent morality - legality, or L. L. Fuller's 'inner morality of law' - is the key to establish the general duty to obey the law. Besides, the latter, 'doubtful law' approach opens up the perspectives to a new domain of inquiry on the conditions of subjects who are expected to obey and respect their law that is, the conditions of citizenship or law-abiding morality.

2022-10-02 22:34:00
1 はてなブックマーク

2 0 0 0 OA 科学・哲学革命と社会契約説—ホッブズを中心として—

2 0 0 0 OA 国際法と強制

2 0 0 0 OA 「所有的個人主義」批判者としてのハンス・ケルゼン・再説 “純粋法学”のイデオロギー批判的性格とイデオロギー的性格

2 0 0 0 OA 法と言語行為

2 0 0 0 OA 法と自然言語-共通感覚論の観点から

2 0 0 0 OA 田中耕太郎の自然法論

2 0 0 0 OA カール・シュミットの「合法的世界革命」論

2 0 0 0 OA デンマークの法哲学 主にFrederik Vinding Kruseを中心として

2 0 0 0 OA 井上 茂著『法秩序の構造』

2 0 0 0 OA 法律学と論理学

2 0 0 0 OA フランスにおける法哲学と法哲学史

2 0 0 0 OA ラートブルフへの疑いとマックス・ウェーバーの価値観

2 0 0 0 OA 正義論と世界観 プラトン哲学の一考察

2 0 0 0 OA 純粋法学と法律解釈

2 0 0 0 OA 価値相対主義における寛容の問題

2 0 0 0 OA アルトウール・カウフマン著「責任原理」-刑法・法哲学的研究-

2 0 0 0 OA 自然法の論理

2 0 0 0 OA プロレタリアート獨裁の法理 『革命的合法性』の歴史的展開

1 0 0 0 OA 遵法義務は個別的ではない ―法・国家・道徳の相互連関―

1 0 0 0 OA 遵法責務論への道

2 0 0 0 OA デンマークの法哲学主にFrederik Vinding Kruseを中心として

2 0 0 0 OA 井上茂著『法秩序の構造』

2 0 0 0 OA 正義論と世界観プラトン哲学の一考察

2 0 0 0 OA プロレタリアート獨裁の法理『革命的合法性』の歴史的展開