著者
羽田野 慶子
出版者
日本教育社会学会
雑誌
教育社会学研究 (ISSN:03873145)
巻号頁・発行日
vol.75, pp.105-125, 2004-11-15 (Released:2011-03-18)
参考文献数
18
被引用文献数
3 1

The purpose of this paper is to clarify the mechanisms for the reproduction and sustenance of the myth of “male physical superiority” through sport practice, using data from field research in a judo club at a junior high school. The myth of “male physical superiority” refers to the social belief that “males are superior to females in physical capabilities.”The judo club is one of the best sport clubs of the school, and its training is the hardest. Unlike other sport clubs, boys and girls always practice together following the same practice schedule. However, during practice, it is found that they are always gender-segregated, and boy-dominated. That is to say, the gender equality of the practice schedule and gender segregation of the physical relationship are the gender systems of the judo club.In the budo-jo(judo-training room), a fixed “borderline” can be observed between boys and girls. The practiced area for the girls is only a third of the size of that for boys. Girls occasionally try to pass across the “borderline, ” but the subversion is only transitory, and the boys' domination of the budo-jo never wavers.Next, the paper analyzes boy-and-girl pairings for randori(technical training in pairs). When choosing a randori partner, weaker players must ask the stronger players. The boy-and-girl pairings seem like a subversion of gender segregation, but in reality a regularity can be seen in the pairing that does not subvert the male-dominated gender relations. For example, whereas a girl will ask a boy from the same year, boys will only ask girls who are their seniors.Not only judo, but almost all sports have systems that segregate males and females, and prevents them from competing with one another. Gender systems in sport are utilized to sustain the myth of “male physical superiority.” The myth is reproduced by various sport practice, such as the ones observed in a judo club, which are produced from a gender-segregated sport system.

言及状況

外部データベース (DOI)

Twitter (15 users, 17 posts, 15 favorites)

かつてのフェミニズムには「競技の場で女子と男子を分けるのは男の方が優れているという神話を守る為」「男は女に負けるのが怖くて仕方ない為」という理論があった。 図らずもこの理論はトランス女性の台頭により否定された訳で、側から見る分にはとても面白い。 https://t.co/rxYrSYazwB
これは主にフェミニズムの視点からの主張であり、「男性が女性に負けるという男性優位を覆す事態を避けるために、敢えて同格の男女が戦う場を無くしている」という批判である。 下にリンクを張った羽田野 慶子氏の記事はその主張の内容を端的に示している。 https://t.co/rxYrSYazwB
この論文では、結果をより出している女子より男子のほうをすごいと感じる柔道のお話から始まっているんですが、それは競技人口について触れられてないので、ちょっとそのへんどうかなとかも思いますけどね https://t.co/6nltrsj2dC

収集済み URL リスト