著者
松田 克進
出版者
日本哲学会
雑誌
哲学 (ISSN:03873358)
巻号頁・発行日
vol.2017, no.68, pp.9-27, 2017-04-01 (Released:2017-06-14)
参考文献数
23

In this paper, the author offers an overview of some methods that have thus far been used in research on the history of philosophy. From the perspective of philosophical importance, the paper further discusses which kinds of methods are relevant or irrelevant. The examples which are specifically examined in this paper are those of Harry Wolfson, an expert in Medieval Philosophy who treated the history of philosophy exclusively from the view point of diachronic influences; Martial Gueroult, the renowned historian of twentieth century France who studied the internal structure or ‘order of reasons’ of several great philosophical systems of the past; and Jonathan Bennett who examined the history of modern philosophy in the manner of analytic philosophy. After indicating the problem with Wolfson’s method, as well as the difficulty with the idea of Dianoématique which Gueroult developed while producing his monumental works on great philosophers, the author concludes that another possible philosophically significant approach is a method which consists of analyzing the internal structure of some of the past’s philosophical doctrines (like Gueroult and others) and daring (unlike Gueroult) to criticize weaknesses, e. g. an inconsistency, in them. The author calls this method “non-idolizing or de-idolizing structuralism.”

言及状況

外部データベース (DOI)

はてなブックマーク (1 users, 1 posts)

Twitter (21 users, 22 posts, 38 favorites)

②【文献・目次】 <文献> 松田克進「哲学史研究の哲学的意義――哲学史との間合いの取り方」、『哲学』、2017 年 2017 巻 68 号 p. 9-27 https://t.co/yaurkTIOFM <目次> ③―⑦導入 ⑧―… https://t.co/Jq86oWt2Dr
哲学史研究の哲学的意義 https://t.co/WB2jeXV0Ew
松田 克進「哲学史研究の哲学的意義——哲学史との間合いの取り方」 ぼくじしん哲学史研究をどう捉えればいいのかまだわかってないのでひとつたいへん勉強になった。 https://t.co/ZXrOQVgGy5
「なぜ哲学では科学と違って過去の文献がいつまでも読まれるのか?」という問いについて、ゲルーの議論の紹介と批判という形で2017年の日本哲学会シンポジウムのときの松田先生の論文で言及されてましたね。今回読み直すまで忘れてた……。https://t.co/gi5oegwW0F
哲学史研究についてのよさげな論文を見つけた https://t.co/JkORcfasbe
松田克進(龍谷大学)「哲学史研究の哲学的意義─哲学史との間合いの取り方」 https://t.co/qe88J6mO5c

収集済み URL リスト