著者
深田 三徳
出版者
日本法哲学会
雑誌
法哲学年報 (ISSN:03872890)
巻号頁・発行日
vol.2005, pp.1-5,200, 2006-10-30 (Released:2010-02-15)

The Annual Meeting of Legal Philosophy 2005 was held in NAGOYA on November12-13, 2005, under the auspice of Japan Association of Legal Philosophy (JALP). Its general theme was “The Rule of Law in Contemporary Japanese Society-Ideal, Reality and Perspective”. In Japan, “the rule of law” has been emphasized as a basic ideal for the recent judicial reform. In this meeting, the various problems about the ideals, tasks and realities etc. of the rule of law (or Rechtsstaat) in contemporary Japanese society were discussed from the viewpoints of legal philosophy and public law. Six legal philosophers and three public law scholars gave reports and discussed these problems.
著者
深田 三徳
出版者
日本法哲学会
雑誌
法哲学年報 (ISSN:03872890)
巻号頁・発行日
vol.2005, pp.7-17,200, 2006-10-30 (Released:2010-02-15)
参考文献数
13
被引用文献数
1

“The Rule of law” has been used in different meanigs. But this is a legal and political ideal or principle, and there are three kinds of the rule of law. First is the rule of law in the modern constitutional laws of Western countries. Second is the rule of law in Japanese constitutional law, and third is the rule of law as a political ideal. Third one relates to what a good government or legal system should be. At first, the history and development of the rule of law in modern constitutional laws of Western countries is considered. Next, the legal scholars' different views on the rule of law in Japanese constitutional law are examined. Finally, formal conceptions and substantive conceptions about the rule of law as a political ideal are discussed. One of formal conceptions is formal legality, which was maintained by Lon L. Fuller, J.Raz and R.S.Summers etc. This is important for other kinds of the rule of law as well. On the other hand, substantive conceptions maintain the rule of just or good laws. But there is much controversies about what just or good laws are. Other several problems about the rule of law are also discussed.
著者
深田 三徳
出版者
日本法哲学会
雑誌
法哲学年報 (ISSN:03872890)
巻号頁・発行日
vol.1984, pp.100-123, 1985-10-20 (Released:2008-11-17)
参考文献数
26
著者
深田 三徳
出版者
同志社大学
雑誌
同志社法學 (ISSN:03877612)
巻号頁・発行日
vol.58, no.7, pp.2369-2411, 2007-03

本稿は、近年、司法制度改革などとの関連で学問的関心を集めている法の支配について、法哲学の視角から考察しようとするものである。「人の支配」「力の支配」と対比される「法の支配」は多義的であるが、まず英米独仏における近代憲法上の法の支配(ないし法治国家)の歴史的展開について概観している。その後、その影響を受けている日本国憲法上の法の支配とそれをめぐる議論について検討している。そして善き統治・政府のあり方、善き法(システム)のあり方に関係する政治理念(ないし法理念)としての法の支配に照準を合わせ、それを形式的考え方と実質的考え方に区分している。その後で、とくに法の支配の形式的考え方に関連して、L.L.フラー、J.ラズ、R.S.サマーズの見解を比較しながら検討している。